Quick answer: The main difference between third party manufacturing and private labelling is whose formula it is. In third party manufacturing, a licensed factory makes your formula, made to your written specification. In private labelling, you pick a ready, tested formula the factory already makes, and sell it under your brand name. Private labelling is faster and cheaper to start. Third party manufacturing gives you more control and a product that is truly yours.
Key takeaways
- Formula decides the model. Your formula = third party manufacturing. The factory’s formula = private labelling.
- Private labelling is quicker. The formula is already tested, so you mostly wait for label approval, packaging and one production run.
- Third party manufacturing gives more control over herbs, strength and taste, but it needs more time, money and paperwork.
- Your name on the box means responsibility. In both models, a brand named as the marketer can be held responsible under Indian packaging rules.
- The words are used loosely in India. Two factories may mean different things by the same word, so always write the model, formula ownership and exclusivity into your agreement.
In this article
- Two factories, two answers
- The difference in one line
- What third party manufacturing means
- What private labelling means
- Why the words get mixed up
- Side-by-side comparison
- Who owns the formula?
- What goes on the label
- Who is responsible if something goes wrong
- One brand, two routes: an example
- Which route should you choose?
- Questions to ask before you sign
- FAQs
Two factories, two answers: why this question matters
Imagine you call two Ayurvedic factories on the same day. You ask both the same simple question: “Can you make a herbal hair oil for my brand?”
The first factory says, “Yes, we offer private labelling. Choose one of our oils, and we will put your name on it.” The second factory says, “Yes, we do third party manufacturing. Send us your formula.”
Now you are confused. Are they offering the same thing? Is one better? Which one costs less?
You are not alone. This is one of the most common questions new brand owners ask us in Bengaluru. The good news is that the answer is simple once you know what to look for. This article explains the difference between third party manufacturing and private labelling in plain words, with tables, an example and a checklist you can use before you sign anything.
What is the difference between third party manufacturing and private labelling?
Here is the difference between third party manufacturing and private labelling in one line:
Third party manufacturing = the factory makes your recipe. Private labelling = you sell the factory’s recipe under your name.
Think of it like food. If you give a caterer your grandmother’s recipe and ask them to cook it for your restaurant, that is like third party manufacturing. If you buy a caterer’s best-selling dish and serve it on your own plates with your restaurant’s name, that is like private labelling. In both cases, the customer sees only your brand. The difference is where the recipe came from.
Everything else, such as cost, speed, control and paperwork, flows from this one point.
What does third party manufacturing mean?
In third party manufacturing, a licensed Ayurvedic factory (the “third party”) makes a product to your specification. You decide the herbs, the amount of each herb, the format (tablet, capsule, syrup, oil or powder) and the pack. The factory sources the herbs, makes the product in its licensed unit, tests it and packs it.
People in India also call this contract manufacturing. If you have a formula from an Ayurvedic doctor, a family recipe, or a product you want to improve, this is usually the route.
The full process has seven stages, from your brief to dispatch. We explain each stage, with MOQ, costs and licences, in our guide on how Ayurvedic third party manufacturing works.
What does private labelling mean?
In private labelling, the factory already has a range of tested products. You choose one or more of them. The factory then fills that product into your bottle, jar or box, with your brand name and design.
You do not need to create a formula. You do not need to wait for long trials. That is why many first-time brands start here.
Private labelling has a close cousin called white labelling. In white labelling, the same ready product may be sold by many brands at once. In private labelling, you can often agree in writing that the product, or at least its look, is only for you. We cover these choices in detail in our guide to private label Ayurvedic products.
Why do people mix up these two words?
If you search online, you will find the two terms used in very different ways. This is not your fault. The words really are used loosely.
- Global business websites such as Shopify describe private labelling as a product made by a third-party manufacturer for one brand, often with custom features or packaging. In that view, private labelling is a kind of third party manufacturing.
- Some Indian suppliers use the words the other way round. A few say “third party” means the factory’s existing formulas, and “private label” means more custom work.
- Many supplier listings on B2B marketplaces simply tick “Private Label, Third Party, White Label” together, without saying what each one means to them.
So what should you do? Stop worrying about the label and ask about the formula. Ask every factory three things: Whose formula is it? Who owns it? Can you sell it to anyone else? The answers tell you which model you are really buying, whatever name the factory uses.
Third party manufacturing vs private labelling: side-by-side
This table shows how the two models usually compare for an Ayurvedic brand. Your exact terms will depend on your manufacturer and your agreement.
| Point | Third party manufacturing | Private labelling |
|---|---|---|
| Whose formula? | Yours (or one developed for you) | The factory’s ready formula |
| Who owns the formula? | Usually you, if the agreement says so | Usually the factory |
| Time to launch | Longer: samples, approvals and trial batches | Shorter: the formula is already tested |
| Starting cost | Higher: development, trials and testing | Lower: mainly packaging and first batch |
| Minimum order (MOQ) | Often higher, as the batch is made only for you | Often lower, especially for standard products |
| Control over herbs and strength | Full control | Limited; you choose from what exists |
| Is the product unique? | Yes, if you keep the formula private | Not always; others may sell the same formula |
| Product approval | A new product may need fresh permission | Factory may already hold permission for the formula |
| Best for | Doctors, established brands, unique ideas | New brands, quick tests, small budgets |
Notice the pattern. Private labelling trades control for speed. Third party manufacturing trades speed for control. Neither is “better”. The right choice depends on your stage and your goal.
Who owns the formula, and why does it matter so much?
Formula ownership is the most important point in the whole difference between third party manufacturing and private labelling. It is also the point most brand owners forget to put in writing.
Here is why it matters:
- If you own the formula, you can move it to another factory later if prices, quality or service change.
- If the factory owns the formula, you own only your brand name and design. If you leave, you may have to start again with a new product.
- If you paid for development but the agreement is silent, there can be a dispute about who owns the result.
A simple rule helps: if it is not written down, assume you do not own it. Ask for a clause on formula ownership and a confidentiality (non-disclosure) clause before any development work starts.
What goes on the label in each model?
From the outside, a third party product and a private label product can look exactly the same. Both carry your brand name. But the small print on the back tells the real story.
For Ayurvedic medicines, labelling is governed by Rule 161 of the Drugs and Cosmetics Rules, 1945. In both models, the label usually shows:
- “Manufactured by” with the factory’s name, address and manufacturing licence number, and
- “Marketed by” with your company’s name and address as the brand owner.
The batch number, manufacturing and expiry dates, ingredients and directions are also needed. In July 2026, the Ministry of Ayush notified the Drugs (Eleventh Amendment) Rules, 2026. Among other changes, these rules bring a uniform product code on labels and allow long label details to be shared through a QR code or barcode. Ask your manufacturer how your artwork will meet these changes.
If your brand uses a loan licence (applied on Form 24-E), the label details can differ, so check the exact wording with your manufacturer and your state AYUSH office. For a full label checklist, see our guide to what an Ayurvedic label must show.
Who is responsible if something goes wrong?
Many new brand owners think, “The factory made it, so the factory is responsible.” That is only half true.
Indian rules are moving towards one clear idea: the name on the box shares the responsibility.
- Under the Legal Metrology (Packaged Commodities) Rules, 2011, if a brand owner’s name and address appear on the label as the marketer, the brand owner can be held responsible for breaking those packaging rules, for example on net quantity or MRP declarations.
- For modern (allopathic) medicines, the Drugs and Cosmetics Rules were changed so that a marketer shares responsibility for quality with the manufacturer (Rule 84E, with the “marketer” definition in force from 1 March 2021). Ayurvedic medicines follow their own part of the rules, but the direction is clear.
This is true whether you choose third party manufacturing or private labelling. So, in both models, you should:
- Ask for a Certificate of Analysis (CoA) with every batch.
- Agree in writing who handles complaints and recalls, and who pays for them.
- Check that the factory’s licences are valid. You can ask to see them, as you can on our certifications page.
One brand, two routes: a simple example
Example
Ravi runs three medical shops in Hubballi. His customers keep asking for a good herbal hair oil. He also has a family recipe for a triphala-based churna that his grandfather made at home. He wants both under his own brand, “Ravi Naturals”.
For the hair oil, Ravi chooses private labelling. The manufacturer already makes a tested hair oil. Ravi picks a 100 ml bottle, approves his label design and places a small first order. His oil is on his shelves within weeks, and he starts learning what customers like.
For the churna, Ravi chooses third party manufacturing. The recipe is his family’s, so he wants to own it. He shares it with the manufacturer under a non-disclosure agreement. The factory’s team checks the herbs, makes samples and runs a trial batch. It takes longer and costs more, but the product is truly his, and the agreement says he owns the formula.
The lesson: one brand can use both models at the same time. Private labelling gets you to market fast. Third party manufacturing protects what makes you different.
This is an illustrative example, not a real customer story.
Which route should you choose?
Answer these five questions honestly. Count your “A” and “B” answers.
| Question | A: private labelling | B: third party manufacturing |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Do you have your own formula? | No | Yes |
| 2. How soon do you want to launch? | As soon as possible | I can wait a few months |
| 3. What is your starting budget? | Small | Medium to large |
| 4. How important is a unique product? | Nice to have | Very important |
| 5. Do you already have customers? | Not yet | Yes, and they want something special |
Mostly A? Start with private labelling. Launch two or three ready products, learn from real sales, and keep your costs low.
Mostly B? Third party manufacturing is likely the better fit. Budget for samples, trials and testing, and plan your timeline in writing.
A mix? Do what Ravi did. Use private labelling for standard products and third party manufacturing for your hero product.
Can you start with one and switch later?
Yes, and many brands do. A common path is to start with private labelling, find out which product sells best, and then develop your own improved version of it through third party manufacturing. If you plan to do this, choose a factory that offers both services and has its own R&D team, so you do not have to change partners. For the bigger picture of models, licences and costs, read how to start an Ayurvedic business in India.
7 questions to ask before you sign
Whatever the factory calls its service, these questions will show you what you are really getting:
- Whose formula is it, and who will own it after launch?
- Can you sell this same formula to other brands? Can we agree on exclusivity?
- What is the MOQ for each product, and does it change for repeat orders?
- Who gets the product permission, and whose name goes on the label as manufacturer and marketer?
- Which tests are done on raw herbs and finished batches, and will I get a CoA every time?
- What is the written timeline from approval to dispatch?
- Who handles complaints and recalls, and who pays?
If a factory cannot answer these clearly, take that as a warning sign.
How Vasishta Pharma helps with both routes
At Vasishta Pharma in Bengaluru, we offer both models under one roof. If you want to start quickly, our Ayurvedic private label manufacturer service lets you choose from formulations we already make. If you have your own formula, our team can make it for you as a third party manufacturer of Ayurvedic medicine, with formula ownership and confidentiality written into the agreement.
We make tablets, capsules, syrups, oils, powders and more in our GMP, FSSAI and AYUSH licensed facility. You can see our formats on the Ayurvedic manufacturing company page.
Frequently asked questions
What is the main difference between third party manufacturing and private labelling?
The main difference is the formula. In third party manufacturing, the factory makes your own formula to your specification. In private labelling, you sell the factory’s ready, tested formula under your brand. Private labelling is faster and cheaper; third party manufacturing gives more control.
Is private labelling a type of third party manufacturing?
In a broad sense, yes. In both cases another company’s factory makes the product for your brand. In everyday business in India, though, “private labelling” usually means using the factory’s ready formula, while “third party manufacturing” usually means making your own formula.
Is contract manufacturing the same as third party manufacturing?
Yes. In India, contract manufacturing and third party manufacturing are usually used for the same thing: a licensed factory makes a product to your specification under your brand.
Which is cheaper, private labelling or third party manufacturing?
Private labelling is usually cheaper to start, because the formula is already developed and tested. Third party manufacturing often costs more at the start because of samples, trials and testing, but you get a product that is truly yours.
Can the manufacturer sell my private label product to other brands?
It can, unless your agreement says otherwise. Ready formulas are often offered to more than one brand. If you want the product to be only yours, ask for an exclusivity clause in writing.
Whose name appears on the label?
For Ayurvedic medicines, the label usually shows the factory as the manufacturer, with its licence number, and your company as the marketer. A brand named as the marketer can share responsibility under Indian packaging rules, so check your artwork carefully.
Not sure which route fits your brand?
Tell us your product idea, your budget and when you want to launch. Our team in Bengaluru will suggest the right route for you.
Sources and further reading
- Drugs and Cosmetics Rules, 1945: Rule 161 (labelling of Ayurvedic, Siddha and Unani drugs) and Forms 24-D and 24-E.
- Drugs and Cosmetics Rules, 1945: definition of “marketer” (in force from 1 March 2021) and Rule 84E on marketer responsibility.
- Legal Metrology (Packaged Commodities) Rules, 2011, Rule 6 and its explanation on brand owners named as marketers.
- Drugs (Eleventh Amendment) Rules, 2026, notified by the Ministry of Ayush in July 2026.
- Shopify: articles on private label and white label business models.
About this article: This article on the difference between third party manufacturing and private labelling was written by the production and regulatory team at Vasishta Pharmaceuticals, Bengaluru. It gives general business information, not legal or medical advice. Rules change over time, so please confirm current requirements with your state AYUSH office, the Legal Metrology department or a qualified professional before you act.
More from our blog
Keep reading
- White Label Ayurvedic Products vs Private Label vs Custom Formulation: Which Suits Your Brand?White label, private label or custom formulation? Cost, MOQ, exclusivity and rules.Read the guide →
- How Ayurvedic Third Party Manufacturing Works: Process, MOQ, Costs and Licences (2026 Guide)The process, minimum order quantities, costs and licences, step by step.Read the guide →
- Private Label Ayurvedic Products: How to Start Your Own Ayurvedic Brand in IndiaHow to launch your own Ayurvedic brand with a private label partner.Read the guide →

[…] Third Party Manufacturing vs Private Labelling: Key Differences for Ayurvedic Brands21 November 2026 […]